Graded: Mobile Design
Section: Guided Discussions
Discussion Graded — Rubric
Grading date: March 14, 2026
Result
Passed — Passing grade: 60%Grade Distribution
Instructor (70%)
82/100
Peer Review (30%)
22/30
February 28, 2026
Mobile-First or Desktop-First?
In a world where over 60% of users are on mobile phones, should we always design mobile-first? Or are there cases where Desktop-First is better?
Your Reply
I believe in the Mobile-First approach in most cases, especially for consumer products. But there are important exceptions like project management tools (Jira, Asana) and design tools (Figma) where Desktop-First is more suitable because users need a large workspace.
Assessment Details — Rubric
Analysis Quality
30/40Excellent
(40)
Good
(30)
Accepted
(20)
Poor
(10)
Good analysis but needs more examples
Practical Examples
30/30Excellent
(30)
Good
(20)
Accepted
(10)
Poor
(5)
Excellent and diverse examples
Writing Quality
22/30Excellent
(30)
Good
(22)
Accepted
(15)
Poor
(5)
Peer Review Results
2 reviews
Comprehensive and helpful reply. I liked the comparative analysis.
March 6, 2026
One of the best replies. Deep analysis with excellent practical examples.
March 7, 2026
Instructor Feedback
Good analysis with practical examples. Could have gone deeper into Desktop-First cases.